Skip to content

In a welcome decision to employers, the Third Circuit decided last week, for the first time, that an employer’s mere “honest belief” that an employee misused FMLA leave is sufficient to defeat a retaliation claim. As an employee claiming retaliation for using protected FMLA leave must prove that the very exercise of that right was a determinative factor in the employer’s decision to take adverse action against her, in other words that there was retaliatory intent, it is good news for employers that they can now successfully defend against claims simply by showing they believed in good faith that the employee misused what was otherwise protected leave. While the Seventh, Eighth, and Tenth Circuits have reached similar decisions, this was previously an open issue in the Third Circuit.

Also of note, the Third Circuit rejected plaintiff’s claim that his employer failed to accommodate his disability under the ADA. While the FMLA (unlike the ADA and most state law analogues) does not require employers to provide reasonable accommodation, a request for leave under the FMLA may under certain circumstances now qualify as a request for a reasonable accommodation under the ADA.

Continue Reading.